Skip to main content

Archived Comments for: Differences in the way a mammalian cell and yeast cells coordinate cell growth and cell-cycle progression

Back to article

  1. Primary cells double their diameter within 1 or 2 passages in vitro.

    Hayden Coon, retired

    30 April 2003

    An excellent paper; interesting, and convincing. I just wondered if the authors had any reaction to the old observation (made independently by Gordon Sato and me) that primary (trypsinized) cells measured at the time of their first plating, double their diameter within 1 or 2 passages. They are pretty stable after that (until senescence sets in). The long term cultured Schwann's cells you have been looking at may well be about 8 times the volume of a freshly liberated (and presumably native) cell. There may be something interesting there...

    Competing interests

    None declared

  2. Primary cells increasing in volume

    Ian Conlon, Author

    8 May 2003

    It is indeed quite an interesting observation, and one that we observed in the isolation and purification steps of our cells. Schwann cells (at least in the conditions we use) do not undergo senescence, so the size of cells proliferating in standard (serum-containing) conditions can be stably maintained after the initial purification steps. The size can be modified, however, depending on the conditions that they are proliferated in. Cells proliferating in serum-containing medium are much bigger than cells proliferating in serum-free conditions (see paper), and the size of cells proliferating in serum-free conditions is much more similar to the size of freshly isolated cells. Therefore, I expect the observed increase in size is simply due to the conditions that the cells are put into after isolation. Another complication for Schwann cells is that some of the cells may have started to myelinate at the time of isolation. The isolation procedure results in a loss of the myelinated structure making those cells smaller when freshly isolated than they were in the animal.

    Competing interests

    None declared

  3. Why are primary cells smaller than cultured cells of the same type?

    Martin C. Raff, University College London

    11 August 2003

    It may be that freshly isolated primary cells are smaller than cells that have been in culture for a while because cells in tissues are exposed to relatively low concentrations of growth factors compared to the situation in culture, where growth factors are usually used at saturating concentrations.

    Competing interests

    no competing interests

  4. Critical analysis of the Conlon/Raff model is published

    Stephen Cooper, University of Michigan Medical School

    5 October 2004

    I would like to draw attention of those interested in the model and experiments of Conlon and Raff to a different view of the subject now published in BMC Cell Biology. The paper is:

     Control and maintenance of mammalian cell size

    Stephen Cooper

    BMC Cell Biology 2004, 5:35 (29 September 2004)

    Immediately following this paper is a reply by Conlon and Raff:

    Control and maintenance of mammalian cell size: Response

    Ian Conlon, Martin Raff

    BMC Cell Biology 2004, 5:36 (30 September 2004)

    I look forward to hearing from those with questions, comments, critiques, suggestions, thoughts, or additional ideas on the subject. Please write to me at

    Competing interests

    No competing interests.